CodeGym /課程 /Kotlin SELF /Overloading vs overriding: zenme buyao nonghun

Overloading vs overriding: zenme buyao nonghun

Kotlin SELF
等級 35, 課堂 4
開放

1. Jieshao

Ru guo ni gang kai shi xie you jicheng de daima, na me 「overloading」 he 「overriding」 ting qi lai xiang shi liang ge zai shuo tong yi jian shi: 「wo zuo le yi ge tong ming fangfa, suo yi ta yinggai mou zhong yiyi shang bei ‘tidai’ le ba」。Zhe shi hou Kotlin (lian tong bianyi qi) jiu hui xiang yi ge yange de laoshi: 「bu bu, pengyou, zhe liang ge shi wanquan bu tong de dongxi」。Li jie zhe ge chayi bing bu shi wei le bei shuyu, er shi yinwei fouze daima sui ran neng yunxing, dan bu hui an ni yuqi de fangshi gongzuo — ye jiu shi shuo, te bie shi he yong lai zhongxia nazhong „an jing“ de bug, ran hou mou tian tu ran zai baogao、log he ni de zixin li bian baozha.

Wo men xian cong yi fu geng „renlei“ de tujing kai shi:

  • Overloading — zai tong yi ge difang (tongchang shi tong yi ge class) li, ni dingyi le duo ge tong ming function, dan can shu bu tong.
  • Overriding — ni zai subclass li dui base class de method ti gong xin de shixian, er qie zai duotai diaoyong shi yinggai zhixing zhe ge shixian.

2. Overloading: zai bianyi qi an can shu xuan ze

Overload shi yi zhong qingkuang: ni you ji ge tong ming function, dan signature bu tong. Zai zhe li wo men zhuyao ba signature li jie wei can shu de zuhe (shuliang、leixing、shunxu). Fanhuizhi leixing dan du bu neng „jiu“ overload: Kotlin bu yunxu liang ge function jinjin yinwei fanhuizhi leixing bu tong er gongcun, yinwei na yang bianyi qi hen nan mingque pan duan ni xiang yao na yi ge.

Overload de xuan ze fa sheng zai bianyi qi: bianyi qi hui gen ju diaoyong shi de argument lai tiao xuan zui heshi de banben. Zhe you dian xiang yong zhengque de yaoshi kai suo: 「en, zhe li shi Int, na jiu xuan format(Int)」。

Mini li zi: zai tong yi ge class li overload format(...)

Jia she wo men zai yi ge kongzhi tai caiwu jizhang app (jiu jiao ta BudgetCLI ba) li, xiang yao piaoliang di da yin shuzi he zifuchuan. Wo men ke yi gei tong yi ge function liang ge banben:


class ValueFormatter {

    fun format(x: Int): String = "int=$x"

    fun format(x: String): String = "str=\"$x\""
}

fun main() {
    val f = ValueFormatter()

    println(f.format(10))        // int=10
    println(f.format("ok"))      // str="ok"
}

Zhe li mei you jicheng, mei you open, ye mei you override. Zhi shi liang ge tong ming dan bu tong de method. Ru guo ni chuan 10, bianyi qi jiu xuan format(Int). Ru guo chuan "ok", jiu xuan format(String).

Xin shou chang you de xiangfa: 「overload jiu shi wei le fangbian diaoyong」

Zhe ju hua da ti shang mei cuo, dan you ge xiaoxijie. You shi hou ni zuo overload, shi wei le ti gong 「jianhua de diaoyong」 he 「xiangxi de diaoyong」:

class MoneyPrinter {

    fun print(amountCents: Int) {
        println("Amount: ${amountCents / 100.0}")  // Amount: 12.34 (for example)
    }

    fun print(amountCents: Int, currency: String) {
        println("Amount: ${amountCents / 100.0} $currency") // Amount: 12.34 USD
    }
}

Zhe jiu shi overload: liang ge print, dan can shu lie biao bu tong.

Overloading he default parameter: ganjue hen xiang, ji zhi bu tong

Hen rongyi ba overload gen default parameter nonghun, yinwei cong diaoyong zhe de jiao du kan xiaoguo hen xiang: 「wo keyi xie duan yi dian, ye keyi xie xiangxi yi dian」。Dan ji zhi bu yi yang: default parameter shi tong yi ge method, zhi shi keyi yong bu tong fangshi diaoyong; overload shi duo ge method.

Zhe shi bu yong overload, zhi yong default parameter de xie fa (wo men zhi qian zai xue function shi you kan guo):

class MoneyPrinter {

    fun print(amountCents: Int, currency: String = "USD") {
        println("Amount: ${amountCents / 100.0} $currency") // for example: Amount: 12.34 USD
    }
}

Cong shijian shang shuo, ni geng chang hui xuan ze default parameter, yi bi mian sheng chu tai duo overload. Dan jin tian zhe tang ke de zhuyao yisi shi: overloading bu shi guanyu jicheng, ye bu shi guanyu „ti huan“ xingwei.

3. Overriding: zai yunxing shi xuan ze shixian

Override shi yi ge wanquan gen jicheng bang zai yiqi de gushi: wo men you yi ge base class, li mian you yi ge method (huo property) tongguo open yunxu bei override, ran hou zai subclass li xie override bing ti gong zi ji de shixian. Zhongyao de shi Kotlin ba zhe jian shi zuo de feichang 「xianxing」: ru guo ni wang le xie override, bianyi qi yi ding hui ba ni jiao zhu. Zhe ye shi wei shenme ren men chang shuo Kotlin shi yi ge 「bu rang ni bu xiaoxin nong huai zheng ge zhi an」 de yuyan.

Override de xuan ze fa sheng zai yunxing shi (runtime) — dang program yi jing zai pao. Ye jiu shi shuo, x.render() dao di jiao yong na ge shixian, bu shi kan bianliang x zai daima li de static type, er shi kan li mian zhenzheng fang de shi na ge class de object.

Mini li zi: zai subclass li override method

open class ReportLine {
    open fun render(): String = "line"
}

class HeaderLine(private val title: String) : ReportLine() {
    override fun render(): String = "== $title =="
}

fun main() {
    val line: ReportLine = HeaderLine("January")
    println(line.render())   // == January ==
}

Qing zhu yi yi ge guanjian dian: bianliang line de type shi ReportLine, dan li mian fang de shi HeaderLine. Suo yi diaoyong render() shi, hui yong subclass de shixian — zhe jiu shi duotai de zhenshi yanshi, bing qie shi yi override wei jichu.

Zai Kotlin li, overriding xuyao tongguo open „shou dong shouquan“

Zai Kotlin li, ni bu tai ke neng 「bu xiaoxin」 override le shenme, yinwei:

1) base class bixu shi open, cai neng bei jicheng;
2) base class li de method bixu shi open, cai neng bei override;
3) subclass li bixu mingque xie override.

Zhe san dao baohu you shi hou kan qi lai hen „gui mao“, dan zai shijian li, ta neng jiu ni yu wuxu „mo fa qia qiao“: ni yiwei zi ji override le, jieguo qi shi zhi shi you xie le ling yi ge method.

4. Zui da xianjing: xiang overriding, que zuo cheng le overloading

Zui weixian de hunxiao shi zhe yang: ni zai subclass li xie le yi ge tong ming method, dan can shu shao you bu tong; bianyi qi bu baocuo, project ye neng build, ni hen kaixin… ran hou dang ni yong base type qu diaoyong shi, jing ran zhi xing de shi base shixian. Zhe shi hou ni jiu hui huaiyi you ren zai zheng ni.

Wei le kan de geng qingchu, wo men ba li zi fang jin jiaxiang de BudgetCLI. Jia she wo men you tongzhi fa song (jiu suan zhi shi da yin dao kongzhi tai): base sender hui 「fa song xiaoxi」, er „email sender“ xiang yao zhi dao shou jian ren.

Base class

open class Sender {
    open fun send(text: String) {
        println("send: $text") // send: ...
    }
}

Subclass (dai xianjing)

class EmailSender : Sender() {

    fun send(text: String, to: String) { // this is NOT override; it's overload
        println("send to $to: $text")     // send to ...
    }
}

Cong renlei jiao du kan 「hen heli」: EmailSender ye hui send, na bu jiu shi „huan yong xin banben“ ma? Dan cong yuyan de jiao du kan, zhe shi liang ge bu tong method: send(String) he send(String, String).

Zui zhongyao de lai le: wo men kan yi xia na zhong jie shou base type de daima (zhe jiushi ni xue wan duotai hou hen chang yong de xie fa).

fun notifyUser(sender: Sender) {
    sender.send("Budget report is ready")
}

fun main() {
    val s: Sender = EmailSender()
    notifyUser(s) // send: Budget report is ready
}

Zui hou de output hai shi base de:

send: Budget report is ready

Wei shenme? Yinwei notifyUser zhi zhi dao Sender.send(String) zhe ge contract. Er send(String, String) gen ben bu shi zhe ge contract de yi bu fen. Ta cun zai, dan ta shi 「pangbian de」, duotai ye „kan bu dao“ ta.

Zhenzheng de overriding chang shenme yang

Ru guo yao bian cheng override, signature bixu wanquan yi yang, er qie subclass yao xie override:

class EmailSender(private val defaultTo: String) : Sender() {

    override fun send(text: String) {
        println("send to $defaultTo: $text") // send to ...
    }
}

Xian zai tong yang yong base type qu diaoyong, jiu hui de dao bu tong de xingwei — zhe cai shi wo men dui jicheng tongchang de yuqi.

5. Bianyi qi ruhe xuan ze method

Ba overload he override fenqing chu, dui ni feichang you bangzhu: ta men fenbie zai bu tong de „zhenxiang shike“ fa sheng. Zhe liang ge shike wanquan bu yi yang.

Wo men hua yi ge hen xiao de liu cheng tu: dui, programer hen ai hua tu — bu ran zenme jie shi bianyi qi tou nao li zai fa shenme.

flowchart TD
    A["Code: f(x)"] --> B{"Are there multiple f(...) with different parameters?"}
    B -- "Yes" --> C["Overloading: choose by argument types (compile-time)"]
    B -- "No" --> D{"Method open + override exists in the class hierarchy?"}
    D -- "Yes" --> E["Overriding: choose by the real object type (runtime)"]
    D -- "No" --> F["Normal call of a single method"]

Overload zhuyao shi guanyu 「can shu zuhe he bu he shi」。Override ze shi guanyu 「base type bianliang li zhenzheng zhuang de shi na yi zhong object」。

Biao ge: overloading vs overriding

Wei le jia shen qubie, ba zhe liang zhe fang zai yi zhang biao ge li bi jiao hen fangbian. Ta bu hui ti dai ni de li jie, dan dang ni zai daima li „bu tai queding zhe dao di shi shenme“ shi, hui feichang you yong.

Tezheng Overloading Overriding
Fa sheng zai na li Tongchang zai tong yi ge class (huo tong yi zu function) li Zai 「base → subclass」 de class hierarchy li
Gai bian le shenme Can shu zuhe (signature) Tong yi ge method de shixian
Xu yao open/override ma Bu xu yao Xu yao: base li open, subclass li override
He shi bei xuan ze Bianyi qi Yunxing shi
Na zhong type geng zhongyao Diaoyong chu argument de types Object de shiji type (duotai)
Changjian mu biao API yong yi: ti gong bu tong de diaoyong fangshi Gai bian huo kuo zhan base class de xingwei

6. Shijian li zi: da yin jiao yi (transaction)

Xian zai wo men zuo yi ge geng xiang „zhen shi xuexi app“ li de daima de li zi, er bu shi chouxiang de Sender. Jia she zai BudgetCLI li, wo men you yi ge base transaction class he liang ge subclass. Wo men bu yong sealed class (zhe ge zhi qian kan guo, dan xian zai wo men zhuyao guanzhu jicheng de ji zhi).

Transaction de base model

open class Transaction(
    val amountCents: Int,
    val note: String
)

class Expense(amountCents: Int, note: String, val category: String) :
    Transaction(amountCents, note)

class Income(amountCents: Int, note: String, val source: String) :
    Transaction(amountCents, note)

Kotlin de jicheng yufa shi yong maohao :, bing diaoyong base class de constructor.

Formatter with overriding

Xian zai wo men zuo yi ge base formatter he yi ge „geng congming“ de formatter. Base ban ben zhi neng „zhao ta hui de fangshi“ da yin, congming ban ben ze da yin de geng xiangxi.

open class TransactionFormatter {

    open fun format(tx: Transaction): String {
        return "amount=${tx.amountCents} note=${tx.note}"
    }
}

class VerboseFormatter : TransactionFormatter() {

    override fun format(tx: Transaction): String {
        return "[TX] " + super.format(tx)
    }
}

Zhe li VerboseFormatter shi zhen de override le format(Transaction), suo yi yong base type diaoyong shi yinggai hui xuan dao zhengque de shixian.

fun printAll(formatter: TransactionFormatter, items: List<Transaction>) {
    for (tx in items) {
        println(formatter.format(tx))
    }
}

fun main() {
    val list = listOf<Transaction>(
        Expense(1500, "Lunch", "Food"),
        Income(250000, "Salary", "Job")
    )

    val f: TransactionFormatter = VerboseFormatter()
    printAll(f, list)
    // [TX] amount=1500 note=Lunch
    // [TX] amount=250000 note=Salary
}

Zhe jiu shi overriding + duotai.

Jia ru overloading, kan kan na li zui rongyi hun

Jia she ni xiang dui Expense tebie „geng congming“ di format, bi ru ba category ye yin chu lai. Yu shi ni xie le:

class VerboseFormatter : TransactionFormatter() {

    override fun format(tx: Transaction): String {
        return "[TX] amount=${tx.amountCents} note=${tx.note}"
    }

    fun format(tx: Expense): String { // overload, not override
        return "[EXPENSE] amount=${tx.amountCents} category=${tx.category}"
    }
}

Kan qi lai hen heli. Dan xian zai kan kan hou guo.

Ru guo ni zhi jie yong Expense qu diaoyong format, bianyi qi hui xuan overload:

fun main() {
    val f = VerboseFormatter()
    val e = Expense(1500, "Lunch", "Food")

    println(f.format(e)) // [EXPENSE] amount=1500 category=Food
}

Dan ru guo ni ba Expense fang zai yi ge Transaction type de bianliang li (zai base type de collection li zhe hui feichang changjian), na overload jiu ke neng cong xuan ze zhong „xiaoshi“:

fun main() {
    val f = VerboseFormatter()

    val tx: Transaction = Expense(1500, "Lunch", "Food")
    println(f.format(tx)) // [TX] amount=1500 note=Lunch
}

Zhe bu shi bug. Zhe shi yi ge zhijie jieguo: overload shi an bianyi qi zai diaoyong dian kan dao de argument type lai xuan, er bu shi an object de shiji type. Shiji type dui overriding cai zhongyao, dui overloading bu zhongyao.

Ru guo ni yuqi de shi da jia dou yin chu "[EXPENSE] ...", na ni xian zai jiu de dao le yi ge hen xianshi de 「wei shenme ta bu gongzuo」.

7. Ruhe bu diao jin xianjing

Kotlin you yi ge hen hao de fanghu ji zhi: ru guo ni zhen de zai override, ni jiu bixu xie override. Zhe dao chu le yi ge feichang shiyong de guize, ke yi bang ni sheng xia hen duo xiao shi:

Dang ni zai subclass li xie yi ge method, bing qie xin li xiang zhe 「wo zai ti huan base de xingwei」, na di yi ge nian tou yinggai shi: 「override zai na li?」。Ru guo override xie bu shang (bianyi qi baocuo), na jiu dai biao ni bu shi override, er shi zai zuo ling wai yi jian shi.

Zhe zai ni bu queding signature shi fou yi yang shi ye hen you yong. Ni ke yi xian xie override — bianyi qi yao me queren, yao me gao su ni wei shenme zhe bu shi override. Kotlin zai zhe li jiu xiang ni de pair partner: bu rang ni 「an jing di fan cuo」.

8. Changjian cuowu

Cuowu №1: 「Zai subclass li jia le yi ge tong ming method, jiu suan override le」.
Zai ni hai mei jia/jian can shu, huo mei gai argument type zhi qian, zhe yang xiang kan qi lai hen you daoli. Dan yi dan ni gai le can shu, ni qi shi shi zai chuangjian overload, er bu shi override. Changjian zhengzhuang shi: yong base type diaoyong shi zhi xing base ban ben, er ni „xin xie de“ hao xiang bei wushi le.

Cuowu №2: yiwei overload hui an object de shiji type bei xuan ze.
Zhe shi feichang pu bian de hunxiao: 「object ming ming shi Expense, wei shenme mei you jiao format(Expense)?」。Yinwei overload shi bianyi qi xuan de, ta kan de shi diaoyong dian bianliang de type. Ru guo bianliang type shi Transaction, bianyi qi jiu hui laoshi di xuan format(Transaction), jiushi li mian zhen de fang le Expense ye yi yang.

Cuowu №3: xiang zai diaoyong chu yong type check lai 「xiu fu」 zhe ge wenti.
Zai qian yi ge cuowu zhi hou, hen rongyi chan sheng yi ge youhuo: zai diaoyong fang xie when (tx) { is Expense -> ... }. You shi hou zhe shi heli de, dan geng chang de qingkuang shi: zhe yi wei zhe ni de base contract she ji bu gou hao. Ru guo xingwei zhen de yinggai gen ju type bu tong er bu tong, tongchang geng hao de zuo fa shi gei base class yi ge open method, ran hou zai ge ge subclass li override, er bu shi ba luoji san luan di fen san dao suo you shi yong zhe de difang.

Cuowu №4: wei le „fangbian“ zuo tai duo overload, zui hou kai shi hu xiang chong tu.
Overload hao yong, qian ti shi ta hen zhi guan. Dan ru guo ni dui format(...) zuo le wu ge ban ben, can shu you hen xiang ( Int, Long, Number, nullable/non-nullable ), na ni zong you yi tian hui peng dao overload resolution ambiguity, ran hou kai shi tao yan shi jie. Zhe zhong di fang, changchang geng shi he yong yi ge method, da pei named arguments huo default values (ru guo zhe zhen de shi tong yi ge yiyi shang de contract).

Cuowu №5: yiwei base class bu xie open ye neng override.
Zai Kotlin li, class he member mo ren dou shi final, bu hui rang ni override, chu fei ni mingque yong open shouquan. Ru guo ni xiang yong „lao Java“ na zhong fengge lai jian jicheng (hen duo dongxi mo ren shi virtual), na bianyi qi jiu hui bu duan ti xing ni: 「xian ba base API de heshi he gui ze ding qingchu」.

Cuowu №6: yiwei zhe zhi shi shuyu bu tong, shijian shang „cha bu duo“.
Shijian shang cha hen duo: overload yingxiang de shi bianyi qi gen ju argument xuan na ge ban ben, er override yingxiang de shi duotai diaoyong shi dao di xuan na ge shixian. Ru guo ni de daima you hen duo base type de collection, bing qie yong „tong yi contract“ lai chu li, na overload/override de hunxiao jiu hui bian cheng feichang bu shuang, dan you heqing heli de bug lai yuan.

1
任務
Kotlin SELF, 等級 35, 課堂 4
上鎖
值格式化器
值格式化器
1
任務
Kotlin SELF, 等級 35, 課堂 4
上鎖
友善機器人
友善機器人
1
任務
Kotlin SELF, 等級 35, 課堂 4
上鎖
郵件陷阱
郵件陷阱
1
任務
Kotlin SELF, 等級 35, 課堂 4
上鎖
聰明的發送者
聰明的發送者
1
問卷/小測驗
Inheritance and polymorphism,等級 35,課堂 4
未開放
Inheritance and polymorphism
Inheritance and polymorphism
留言
TO VIEW ALL COMMENTS OR TO MAKE A COMMENT,
GO TO FULL VERSION